Skip to content
Διάρκεια άρθρου: Λιγότερο από 1 λεπτό Λεπτά

They Made Time for Kirill’s Birthday. What About Orthodox Unity?

By Sotirios M. Tzoumas 

The first concelebration of Patriarchs John and Theophilos took place neither in Constantinople, nor in Damascus, nor in Jerusalem, but in… Moscow! Shame on them!

Thirteen years into John X’s tenure on the Throne of Antioch, his first concelebration with Patriarch Theophilos III of Jerusalem took place in Moscow, at the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour, as part of the celebrations marking Patriarch Kirill’s 80th birthday.

Damascus, Balamand and the Holy Sepulchre, places that would have given this encounter an ecclesiastical significance of its own, were left out of the picture. It took Kirill’s birthday for us to see two primates of ancient patriarchal sees standing before the same Chalice.

Their concelebration is always a cause for joy. Precisely because it matters so much, we are entitled to question the occasion they chose to do so publicly.

The sacrament of the Eucharist is one thing. The public responsibility of those who decide when, where and on what occasion to make a gesture of such symbolic weight is another.

John and Theophilos owe us an explanation for that choice.

The dispute over ecclesiastical jurisdiction in Qatar had led Antioch to cease commemorating the Patriarch of Jerusalem. In October 2023, after war had already broken out in Gaza, the Holy Synod of Antioch resolved to restore communion.

The two primates later met in Jordan as well. They had both the time and the ecclesiastical grounds to concelebrate in the Middle East, alongside their own people. Imagine what it would have meant to the beleaguered Christians of the region to witness their shepherds’ reconciliation at the Holy Sepulchre or in Damascus. They let that opportunity pass. Yet for Moscow and for Kirill’s sake, they sprang into action. It seems the sound of roubles is sweeter!

Here lies the gravest point. According to the report, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew was left uncommemorated at the Moscow liturgy, in keeping with the Russian Church’s 2018 decision to break Eucharistic communion. The two patriarchs thus made a public show of their own reconciliation at a liturgical gathering that still bore the mark of another rupture. Both know full well what it means when a primate is no longer commemorated. They lived through it for years in their own relations. One would have expected greater sensitivity from them when that same wound concerns Constantinople.

Your Beatitude, Patriarch of Antioch, your Church made a courageous decision in 2023, in the midst of war. We honour that decision. You would honour it more fully by giving equal weight to a meeting that could help the Churches speak to one another again. Antioch’s ancient apostolic standing gives you the authority to take the initiative. Use it.

Your Beatitude, Patriarch of Jerusalem, you often invoke the title “Mother of the Churches.” That motherhood carries a responsibility to seek out your brothers when communion is strained and to come to the table when you are called to discuss difficult matters. Your eagerness to attend Kirill’s celebration has already shown how swiftly you can respond to an invitation when you consider it important. We look forward to seeing the same eagerness at the Phanar.

The two primates have been invited to Constantinople on 30 November, the feast of Saint Andrew and the patronal feast of the Ecumenical Patriarchate. A Synaxis of the Primates of the ancient patriarchates is planned as part of the celebrations, with Patriarch Theodore II of Alexandria also taking part. There they can air their disagreements frankly. Their presence would matter precisely because those disagreements exist. By staying away, they would leave one question unanswered. How much do they really care about healing the rift they speak of in their public statements?

For Kirill’s 80th birthday, they made the trip and posed for the photographs. On 30 November, John and Theophilos have the opportunity to show, by their presence, how high they place Orthodox unity among their priorities.

If they stay away, they will owe their faithful an explanation for why the road to Moscow was so easy to find, while the road to the Phanar proved so difficult.

Otherwise, we will have this to say. Your Beatitudes of Antioch and Jerusalem, someone greater than you got there first, on the road to Damascus and Jerusalem. You proved yourselves small!

Το πρωτότυπο άρθρο https://exapsalmos.gr/they-made-time-for-kirills-birthday-what-about-orthodox-unity/ ανήκει στο Εξάψαλμος .
‹ ›